Development of a procedure for ranking the administrative territories in the constituent entities of the Russian Federation according to the degree of risk for complicating the epizootiological and epidemiological situation of anthrax on the basis of multivariate analysis


DOI: https://dx.doi.org/10.18565/epidem.2022.12.4.26-33

Logvin F.V., Kulichenko A.N., Buravtseva N.P., Ryazanova A.G., Gerasimenko D.K., Chmerenko D.K., Mezentsev V.M., Dubyansky V.M., Aksenova L.Yu., Semenova O.V., Golovinskaya T.M.

1) Rostov State Medical University, Ministry of Health of Russia, Rostov-on-Don, Russia; 2) Stavropol Plague Control Research Institute, Russian Federal Service for Supervision of Consumer Rights Protection and Human Well-Being, Stavropol, Russia
Objective. To develop a procedure for determining the minimum set of available criteria for ranking the administrative territories in the constituent entities of the Russian Federation according to the degree of risk for complicating the epizootiological and epidemiological situation of anthrax on the basis of multivariate analysis (in case of the constituent entities of the North Caucasian and Southern Federal Districts).
Materials and methods. The investigators used information from the Directorates for the Republic of Dagestan, the Stavropol Territory, and the Rostov Region, Russian Federal Service for Supervision of Consumer Rights Protection and Human Well-Being. Assessing the risks for anthrax provided the ranking factors characterizing the epizootiological and epidemiological activity of the actualized settlements permanently unfavorable for anthrax (PUSs) in the administrative territorial units (ATUs) of the constituent entities: amounts (R1) and number of years of activity (R2) of PUSs, proportion of active PUSs (R3) and number of years of activity years (R4) over the last 10 years, multiplicity of PUS activity (R5), density (R6) and specific gravity (R7) of PUSs, and epizootic index (R8). The investigators explored the following procedures: ∑R1-8, ∑R1-7, ∑R1-6, ∑R1-5, ∑R1-5.7, and ∑R1-5.8.
Results. Significant differences (p ≤ 0.05) in the division of ATUs in the constituent entities into 4 risk groups were found in most cases of comparison: between ∑R1-8 and ∑R1-6, ∑R1-5 (the Republic of Dagestan), ∑R1-6, ∑R1-5, ∑R1- 5.7, ∑R1-5.8 (the Stavropol Territory), ∑R1-7, ∑R1-6, ∑R1-5 (the Rostov Region). At the same time, the ∑R1-8 procedure more accurately and objectively reflected the situation and risks of anthrax, whereas the exclusion of factors caused a distortion of the results.
Conclusion. To rank the constituent entities of the Russian Federation, a ∑R1-8-based approach is proposed to make evidence-based planning of preventive measures to improve infection surveillance in the country.

Literature


1. Логвин Ф.В., Кондратенко Т.А., Водяницкая С.Ю. Сибирская язва в мире, странах СНГ и Российской Федерации (обзор литературы). Медицинский вестник Юга России 2017; 8(3): 17–22. DOI: 10.21886/2219-8075-2017-8-3-17-22


Logvin F.V., Kondratenko T.A., Vodyanitskya S.Yu. [Anthrax in the world, CIS and Russian Federation (literature review)]. Medical Herald of the South of Russia 2017; 8(3): 17–22. (In Russ.). DOI: 10.21886/2219-8075-2017-8-3-17-22


2. Дугаржапова З.Ф., Чеснокова М.В., Гольдапель Э.Г., Косилко С.А., Иннокентьева Т.И., Балахонов С.В. Сибирская язва в азиатской части Российской Федерации. Сообщение 1. Исторические сведения о распространенности болезни в Сибири и на Дальнем Востоке. Проблемы особо опасных инфекций 2017; (1): 54–8. DOI: 10.21055/0370-1069-2017-1-54-58


Dugarzhapova Z.F., Chesnokova M.V., Gol’dapel’ E.G., Kosilko S.A., Innokent’eva Т.I., Balakhonov S.V. [Anthrax in the Asian part of the Russian Federation. Communication 1. Historical remarks on the spread of the disease in Siberia and Far East]. Problems of Particularly Dangerous Infections 2017; (1): 54–58. (In Russ.). DOI: 10.21055/0370-1069-2017-1-54-58


3. Попова А.Ю., Ежлова Е.Б., Демина Ю.В., Куличенко А.Н., Рязанова А.Г., Буравцева Н.П. и др. Пути совершенствования эпидемиологического надзора и контроля за сибирской язвой в Российской Федерации. Проблемы особо опасных инфекций 2017; (1): 84–8. DOI: 10.21055/0370-1069-2017-1-84-88


Popova A.Yu., Ezhlova E.B., Demina Yu.V., Kulichenko A.N., Ryazanova A.G., Buravtseva N.P. et al. [Ways to improve the epidemiological surveillance and control of anthrax in the Russian Federation]. Problems of Particularly Dangerous Infections 2017; (1): 84–8. (In Russ.). DOI: 10.21055/0370-1069-2017-1-84-88


4. Попова А.Ю., Куличенко А.Н. (ред). Опыт ликвидации вспышки сибирской язвы на Ямале в 2016 году. Ижевск: ООО «Принт-2», 2017. 313 с.


Popova A.Y., Kulichenko A.N. (eds.). [The experience of elimination of anthrax outbreak in the Yamal in 2016]. Izhevsk: ООО Print-2; 2017. 313 p. (In Russ.).


5. Горячева Н.Г., Авитисов П.В., Семиног В.В., Глотов Е.Н. Развитие мониторинга биологических угроз почвенных очагов сибирской язвы Научные и образовательные проблемы гражданской защиты 2016; 28(1): 41–6.


Goryacheva N.G., Avitisov P.V., Seminog V.V., Glotov E.N. [Development monitoring of soil biological threats foci of anthrax]. Scientific and educational problems of civil protection 2016; 28(1): 41–6. (In Russ.).


6. Черкасский Б.Л. Эпидемиология и профилактика сибирской язвы. М.: ИНТЕРСЭН, 2002. 384 с.


Cherkassky B.L. [Epidemiology and prevention of anthrax]. Moscow: INTERSEN, 2002. 384 p. (In Russ.).


7. Раичич С.Р., Сабурова С.А., Шабейкин А.А., Симонова Е.Г. Оценка ситуации по сибирской язве на основе ранжирования территорий по степени риска. Проблемы особо опасных инфекций 2020; (4): 125–32. DOI: 10.21055/0370-1069-2020-4-125-132


Raichich S.R., Saburova S.A., Shabeikin A.A., Simonova E.G. [Assessment of the situation on anthrax based on ranking territories by the degree of risk]. Problems of Particularly Dangerous Infections 2020; (4): 125–32. (In Russ.). DOI: 10.21055/0370-1069-2020-4-125-132


8. Логвин Ф.В., Кондратенко Т.А., Водяницкая С.Ю., Рыжова А.А., Водопьянов А.С., Жилин В.Г. и др. Результаты комплексной оценки территории Ростовской области по сибирской язве по степени эпизоотолого-эпидемиологической опасности. Медицинский вестник Юга России 2017; 8(4): 93–8. DOI: 10.21886/2219-8075-2017-8-4-93-98


Logvin F.V., Kondratenko T.A., Vodyanitskaya S.Yu., Ryzhova A.A., Vodopyanov A.S., Zhilin V.G. et al. [Complex assessment results of the Rostov region territories on anthrax epizootic and epidemiological danger degree]. Medical Herald of the South of Russia 2017; 8(4): 93–8. (In Russ.). DOI: 10.21886/2219-8075-2017-8-4-93-98


9. Буравцева Н.П., Антюганов С.Н., Семенко О.В., Рязанова А.Г., Еременко Е.И., Куличенко А.Н. и др. Эпизоотолого-эпидемиологическое районирование территории Северо-Кавказского федерального округа по степени неблагополучия по сибирской язве с использованием программы Arc GIS10. Журнал микробиологии, эпидемиологии и иммунобиологии 2016; (3): 19–24. DOI: 10.36233/0372-9311-2016-3-19-24


Buravtseva N.P., Antyuganov S.N., Semenko O.V., Ryazanova A.G., Eremenko E.I., Kulichenko A.N. et al. [Epizootological and epidemiological zoning of the territory of North Caucasus Federal Region by a degree of non-welfare by anthrax using ArcGIS10 program]. Journal of microbiology, epidemiology and immunology 2016; (3): 19–24. (In Russ.).


10. Дугаржапова З.Ф., Ивачева М.А., Чеснокова М.В., Кравец Е.В., Решетняк Е.А., Уманец А.А. и др. Сибирская язва в Приморском крае (1919–2020 гг.). Сообщение 2. Эпизоотолого-эпидемиологическая ситуация и районирование административных территорий. Проблемы особо опасных инфекций 2021; (4): 67–78. DOI: 10.21055/0370-1069-2021-4-67-78


Dugarzhapova Z.F., Ivacheva M.A., Chesnokova M.V., Kravets E.V., Reshetnyak E.A., Umanets A.A. et al. [Antrax in Primorsky Territory (1919–2020). Communication 2. Episootiological-epidemiological situation and zoning of administrative territories]. Problems of Particularly Dangerous Infections 2021; (4): 67–78. DOI: 10.21055/0370-1069-2021-4-67-78 (In Russ.).


11. Симонова Е.Г., Раичич С.Р., Картавая С.А., Лок­тионова М.Н., Шабейкин А.А. Проявления активности стационарно неблагополучных по сибирской язве пунктов Российской Федерации в современных условиях. Проблемы особо опасных инфекций 2018; (2): 90–94. DOI: 10.21055/0370-1069-2018-2-90-94


Simonova E.G., Raichich S.R., Kartavaya S.A., Loktionova M.N., Shabeikin A.A. [Manifestation of activity of potentially hazardous as regards anthrax areas across the Russian Federation under current conditions]. Problems of Particularly Dangerous Infections 2018; (2): 90–94. (In Russ.). DOI: 10.21055/0370-1069-2018-2-90-94


12. Водопьянов А.С., Водяницкая С.Ю., Логвин Ф.В., Баташев В.В., Водопьянов С.О., Олейников И.П. и др. Использование ГИС-технологий на основе пространственного анализа для разработки методики риск-ориентированной оценки потенциальной опасности территорий по сибирской язве в Ростовской области. Медицинский вестник Юга России 2016; (3): 46–50. DOI: 10.21886/2219-8075-2016-3-46-50


Vodopyanov A.S., Vodyanitskya S.Yu., Logvin F.V., Batashev V.V., Vodopyanov S.O., Oleynikov I.P. et al. [Usage of GIS-technologies based on the spatial analysis for development of the risk assessment techniques of potential hazard of Rostov Region‘s territories due to anthrax]. Medical Herald of the South of Russia 2016; (3): 46–50. (In Russ.). DOI: 10.21886/2219-8075-2016-3-46-50


13. Симонова Е.Г., Локтионова М.Н., Картавая С.А., Хадарцев О.С. Сибирская язва: оценка эпизоотолого-эпидемиологического риска в Российской Федерации на современном этапе. Эпидемиология и вакцинопрофилактика 2013; 69(2): 5–11.


Simonova E.G., Loktionova M.N., Kartavaya S.A., Hadartsev O.S. [Anthrax: epizootological and epidemiological risk assessment in the Russian Federation at the present stage]. Epidemiology and Vaccinal Prevention 2013; (2): 5–11. (In Russ.).


14. Базарова Г.Х., Лукьяненко Н.В., Рождественский Е.Н., Салдан И.П., Шевченко В.В. Характеристика стационарно неблагополучных по сибирской язве пунктов на современном этапе развития в Алтайском крае. Проблемы особо опасных инфекций 2017; (2): 9–12.


Bazarova G.K., Luk’yanenko N.V., Rozhdestvensky E.N., Saldan I.P., Shevchenko V.V. [Characteristics of stationary hazardous as regards anthrax areas in Altai Territory in the modern period]. Problems of Particularly Dangerous Infections 2017; (2): 9–12. (In Russ.). DOI: 10.21055/0370-1069-2017-2-9-12. (In Russ.).


15. Мицаев Ш.Ш. Сибирская язва в Чеченской Республике. Махачкала: АЛЕФ (ИП Овчинников М.А.), 2016. 182 с.


Micaev Sh.Sh. [Anthrax in the Chechen Republic]. Mahachkala: ALEF (IP Ovchinnikov M.A.), 2016. (In Russ.).


16. Определение эпидемиологической опасности почвенных очагов сибирской язвы. Методические рекомендации МР 3.1.0232-21 https://www.garant.ru/products/ipo/prime/doc/400555146/


[Biometric method determination of epidemiological danger of soil foci of anthrax, Methodological recommendations MR 3.1.0232-21]. https://www.garant.ru/products/ipo/prime/doc/400555146/


17. Урбах В.Ю. Биометрические методы. М.: Наука, 1964. 405 с.


Urbah V.Yu. [Biometric methods]. Moscow: Nauka, 1964. 405 p. (In Russ.).


18. Гланц С. Медико-биологическая статистика. М.: Практика, 1999. 459 с.


Glantz S. [Biomedical statistics]. Moscow: Practice; 1999. 459 p. (In Russ.).


19. Черкасский Б.Л., Форстман Д.В., Локтионова М.Н., Шабейкин А.А. Опыт использования ГИС-технологий для изучения закономерностей распределения стационарно неблагополучных по сибирской язве пунктов. Эпидемиология и инфекционные болезни 2005; (6): 19–23.


Cherkassky B.L., Forstman D.V., Loktionova M.N., Shabeykin A.A. [Experience in the use of GIS technologies to study the patterns of distribution of stationary unfavorable sites for anthrax]. Epidemiology and Infectious Diseases 2005; (6): 19–23. (In Russ.).


About the Autors


Fedor V. Logvin, Cand. Med. Sci., Associate Professor, Rostov State Medical University, Ministry of Health of Russia, Rostov-on-Don, Russia; atlz3@mail.ru; https://orcid.org/0000-0002-4410-1677
Professor Aleksandr N. Kulichenko, Corresponding Member of the Russian Academy of Sciences, MD, Director, Stavropol Antiplague Institute, Russian Federal Service for Supervision of Consumer Rights Protection and Human Well-Being, Stavropol, Russia; stavnipchi@mail.ru; https://orcid.org/0000-0002-9362-3949
Professor Nina P. Buravtseva, MD, Principal Researcher, Stavropol Antiplague Institute, Russian Federal Service for Supervision of Consumer Rights Protection and Human Well-Being, Stavropol, Russia; anthraxlab.stv@mail.ru; https://orcid.org/0000-0002-0756-5405
Alla G. Ryazanova, Cand. Med. Sci., Bacteriologist, Head, Anthrax Laboratory, Stavropol Antiplague Institute, Russian Federal Service for Supervision of Consumer Rights Protection and Human Well-Being, Stavropol, Russia; anthraxlab.stv@mail.ru; https://orcid.org/0000-0002-5196-784X
Diana K. Gerasimenko, Biologist, Stavropol Antiplague Institute, Russian Federal Service for Supervision of Consumer Rights Protection and Human Well-Being, Stavropol, Russia; diana-gerasimenko-95@mail.ru; https://orcid.org/0000-0002-8636-6585
Dmitry K. Chmerenko, Junior Researcher, Stavropol Antiplague Institute, Russian Federal Service for Supervision of Consumer Rights Protection and Human Well-Being, Stavropol, Russia; dmitry.tchmerenko@yandex.ru; https://orcid.org/0000-0002-2143-2668
Vladimir M. Mezentsev, Cand. Med. Sci., Epidemiologist, Stavropol Antiplague Institute, Russian Federal Service for Supervision of Consumer Rights Protection and Human Well-Being, Stavropol, Russia; vladmez@inbox.ru; https://orcid.org/0000-0003-0613-861X
Vladimir M. Dubyansky, BD, Head, Department of Epizootiological Monitoring and Forecasting, Stavropol Antiplague Institute, Russian Federal Service for Supervision of Consumer Rights Protection and Human Well-Being, Stavropol, Russia; dvmplague@gmail.com; https://orcid.org/0000-0003-3817-2513
Lyudmila Yu. Aksenova, Cand. Med. Sci., Senior Researcher, Stavropol Antiplague Institute, Russian Federal Service for Supervision of Consumer Rights Protection and Human Well-Being, Stavropol, Russia; anthraxlab.stv@mail.ru; https://orcid.org/0000-0002-7744-3112
Olga V. Semenova, Cand. Biol. Sci., Researcher, Stavropol Antiplague Institute, Russian Federal Service for Supervision of Consumer Rights Protection and Human Well-Being, Stavropol, Russia; anthraxlab.stv@mail.ru; https://orcid.org/0000-0003-0274-898X
Tatiana M. Golovinskaya, Cand. Biol. Sci., Biologist, Stavropol Antiplague Institute, Russian Federal Service for Supervision of Consumer Rights Protection and Human Well-Being, Stavropol, Russia; anthraxlab.stv@mail.ru; https://orcid.org/0000-0001-6475-4512


Similar Articles


Бионика Медиа