Analysis of diagnostic discrepancy cases in a tuberculosis dispensary
DOI: https://dx.doi.org/10.18565/epidem.2019.9.3.71-7
Korzh E.V., Podtchos N.A., Zavgorodnii A.F.
1) M. Gorky Donetsk National Medical University, Donetsk;
2) Republican Clinical Tuberculosis Hospital, Donetsk
Objective. To analyze the reasons for the discrepancy between the preliminary and final clinical diagnoses at a tuberculosis (TB) hospital and to determine the ways of improving the accuracy of diagnosis.
Materials and methods. Sixty-nine medical records were studied in the patients treated at the Republican Clinical Tuberculosis Hospital in Donetsk in 2014–2018, in whom the diagnosis of tuberculosis was removed after examination in the TB department. The patients were divided into groups: 1) HIV-positive (n = 31) and 2) HIV-negative (n = 38). There was a male preponderance in both groups: 17 and 21, respectively; the mean age was 42.3 ± 1.8 and 57.8 ± 2.4 years and the median bed/days were 10 and 11. Bacteriological assays, chest and head spiral computed tomography (SCT), and diagnostic fibrobronchoscopy (FBS) were used.
Results. Exclusion of tuberculosis and clarification of its diagnosis were made in 44 (63.8%) patients within 2 weeks; tuberculosis test therapy was required in 7 (10.1%) patients. The HIV-infected patients were most frequently diagnosed with HIV/AIDS-associated nervous system lesions and pneumonia (including atypical ones); the HIV-negative patients had lung oncopathology (cancer, carcinomatosis). Acid-resistant bacteria detected prior to hospital, unconfirmed in a specialized dispensary, were present in 15 (39.5%) HIV-negative patients.
Conclusion. To improve the accuracy of tuberculosis diagnosis in the facilities of the general medical network, it is necessary to improve the quality of microscopic examination and to prevent the contamination of biological samples. If there are clinical and radiological signs of pneumonia in HIV-infected persons with a negative sputum microscopy, their treatment should be performed in the specialized departments of AIDS centers with repeated consultation of a TB specialist if necessary.
Literature
- Posazhennikova S.Yu. [Mistakes in diagnostic of diseases shown with infiltrative changes in lungs]. Tuberkulez i bolezni legkikh 2015; (5): 156. (In Russ.).
- Laushkina Zh.A., Krasnov V.A. [Features of non tuberculous pulmonary diseases revealed in the phthisiatric hospitals]. Tuberkulez i bolezni legkikh 2016; 94(7): 38–42. https://doi.org/10.21292/2075-1230-2016-94-7-38-42. (In Russ.).
- Demihova O.V., Karpina N.L., Lepeha L.N., Bagirov M.A., Amansahedov R.B. [Ways of optimization of diagnostics and differential diagnosis of disseminated pulmonary tuberculosis]. Vestnik Rossiyskoy аkademi meditsinskikh nauk 2012; (11): 15–21. (In Russ.).
- Gurevich G.L., Skrуagina E.M., Kalechic O.M., Krivonos P.S., Bubel’ L.I., Babchenok A.M., Kral’ko V.Ja., Kudlach N.I., Lantuhov A.V., Novskaуa G.K., Astrovko A.P., Dyusmikeyeva M.I. [Experience of the commission on diagnostics of small forms of tuberculosis without bacterial excretion]. Medicinskaya panorama 2013; (2): 94–5. (In Russ.).
- Lyakh Yu. E., Gur’yanov V.G., Khomenko V.N., Panchenko O.A. [Fundamentals of computer biostatistics. The analysis of information in biology, medicine and pharmacy with statistical MedStat package]. Donetsk: Papakica E.K., 2006. 214 p. (In Russ.).
- Gustov A.V., Ruina E.A., Shilov D.V., Erohina M.N. [Clinical options of damage of nervous system in HIV-infected]. Sovremennye tehnologii v medicine 2010; (3): 61–5. (In Russ.).
- Laushkina Zh.A., Filimonov P.I. Assessment of the factors associated with duration of the period of differential diagnosis of tuberculosis of lungs. Bulletin of the East-Siberian Scientific Center, RAMS Siberian Branch 2011; 78(2): 58–60. https://elibrary.ru/item.asp?id=17011104 (In Russ.)
- Mnyambwa N.P., Ngadaya E.S., Kimaro G., Kim D., Kazwala R., Petrucka P., Mfinanga S.G. Assessment of sputum smear-positive but culture-negative results among newly diagnosed pulmonary tuberculosis patients in Tanzania. Int. J. Gen. Med. 2017; (10): 199–205. https://doi.org/10.2147/IJGM.S137469
About the Autors
Prof. Elena V. Korzh, MD, Professor, Department of Phthisiology and Pulmonology, M. Gorky Donetsk National Medical University, Donetsk; е-mail: Elena-korg@ukr.net
Nina A. Podtchos, Head, Tuberculosis and Pulmonary Department for Adults No. 1, Republican Clinical Tuberculosis Hospital, Donetsk; е-mail: trushinanina@rambler.ru
Aleksandr F. Zavgorodnii, Phthisiatrician, Tuberculosis and Pulmonary Department for Adults No. 1, Republican Clinical Tuberculosis Hospital, Donetsk; е-mail: zavgorodnii-a_sf@mail.ru